After much research, bids, sales calls, and hand wringing, we ordered WeatherShield windows. They beat out Pella and Andersen. We ordered “hurricane” glass so we can do away with our security bars–it will also reduce the noice in the master bedroom (which faces the street). Final cost for about 26 windows and 2 doors will be around $27,000–that includes new sills for the rotted out ones, a storm window over the stained glass window, rubbed bronze hardware on the dining room and kitchen windows. Most of the windows will be double-hung with black aluminum cladding over the outside. We won’t have to worry about painting three stories up on a ladder.
The goal of getting some contractors in here to do messy work while we were on our honeymoon–well, that’s not going to happen.
Good news: Emily researched the house two doors down that just sprouted a For Sale sign. They want $699k for it (and it is a “beater”). That’s $125k more than we paid for ours.